Saturday 24 May 2014

THE CONDITIONS OF SCHOOLS OF ARCHITECTURE IN NIGERIA: Challenges and Solutions*

Scholars at different flora have severally discussed the state of Architectural Education. This has informed the need to overhaul the schools of Architecture in Nigeria, in order to meet the new challenges of the present day; thus, it has become expedient for Architectural education in Nigeria to go beyond manual based method and “move to the next level”. Therefore, the areas of emphasis in this context are:
·                     School curriculum
·                     Information and Communication Technology - ICT
·                     Staff development training opportunities
·                     Funding
The present NIA/ ARCON / NBTE / NUC minimum academic standards for the study of Architecture in Nigeria Universities and Polytechnics need to take into cognisance the prevailing socio-economic and globalization trends, resulting from the “invasion” of the world by computer technology and the ongoing “techno-overhauling” of education curricula in most fields of human endeavour. Little wonder, Adeyemi (1987) stated: “The structure of the curriculum beyond this point should aim at giving expression to and utilizing the factors of socio-economic and technological transformation in the Nigerian nation”. There is therefore the need to focus attention on improving the standard of Architectural education in Nigeria. This paper thus tries to look at how this can be achieved with a view to improving the lot of the Nigerian Architecture students and ultimately the quality of Architectural services rendered in the country.
SCHOOL CURRICULUM
The complexity and dynamism of today’s Architecture, has necessitated the clamour for a change in the Architectural education curricula in the Nigerian Universities and Polytechnics. Today, there are over 20 tertiary institutions (Universities and polytechnics) in Nigeria accredited for the training of Architects. As worthy as the aims and objectives of Architectural education curricula are, their realization still requires being in tune with present day technological advancements. What obtains from the academic curricula of most (if not all) of these schools is the manually based drawing approach (that is, the use of tee-square, drawing board e.t.c) to produce students’ Architectural works. Unfortunately, this approach is no longer in consonance with the present day trends.  Table 1(a – h): National Board of Technical Education (NBTE) curriculum in Nigerian polytechnics
(a)        ND I FIRST SEMESTER
COURSE NO
COURSE TITLE
CONTACT
HOURS/WEEK
CREDIT
UNITS
ARC 111
Free-Hand Sketching I
4
2
ARC 112
Technical Drawing
4
2
ARC 113
Building Construction
5
3
ARC 115
Wood-Workshop Practice
3
2
ARC 116
Mechanics & Heat Energy
3
3
ARC 119/MTH 112
Logic & Linear Algebra
2
2
 BCH 111
General Chemistry
3
3
ARC 114
Basic Principle Of Surveying
4
2
LGE 111
Use of English I
2
2
GNS 110/117
Introductory Sociology/citizenship Education.
3
2
EE 118
Introduction to Computer Management.
2
2

TOTAL
35
25
(b)       ND I SECOND SEMESTER
COURSE NO
COURSE TITLE
CONTACT
HOURS/WEEK
CREDIT
UNITS
ARC 121
Free-Hand Sketching II
3
2
ARC 122
Architectural Graphics I
3
2
ARC 123
Building Construction II
5
3
ARC 124
History of Architecture.
2
2
ARC 125
Basic Design
3
2
ARC 126
Optics, waves, Electronics & Magnetism
5
3
ARC 127
Properties of Material
4
3
ARC 128
Descriptive Geometry
2
2
ARC 129/MTH 122
Algebra & Trigonometry (Elective)
2
2
LGE 121
Communication In English I
2*
2*
GNS 127
Citizenship Education
2
2
CE 115
Concrete Workshop Practice
2
2

TOTAL
35
25/27
(c)        ND II FIRST SEMESTER
COURSE NO
COURSE TITLE
CONTACT
HOURS/WEEK
CREDIT
UNITS
ARC 211
Architectural Design I
6
3
ARC 212
Architectural Graphics II
4
2
ARC 213
Building Construction III
5
3

ARC 214
Traditional Architecture
2
2
ARC 215/MTH 215
Calculus (elective)
2*
2*
ARC 216
Photography & Model Making.
4
2

ARC 218
Strength of materials
4
3
ARC 219
Mechanical/Electrical Workshop Practice
2
2
ARC 130
Basic Elect.Tech & Installation Practice
2
2
LGE 211
Communication in English
2
2
GNS 124
Government
2
2

TOTAL
35
23/25
(d)       ND II SECOND SEMESTER
COURSE NO
COURSE TITLE
CONTACT
HOURS/WEEK
CREDIT
UNITS
ARC 221
Architectural Design II
7
3
ARC 222
Architectural Graphics III
4
2
ARC 223
Building Construction IV
5
3
ARC 224
Introduction to Building Climatology
2
2
ARC 227
Building Services & Equipment
3
3
BA 229
Entrepreneurship Development
2
2
ARC 229/MTH 229
Trigonometry Analytical Geometry (Elective)
2*
2*
ARC 226/GNS 125
Economics
2
2
LGE 221
Communication in English II
3
2
ARC 225
Introduction to Landscape Design
3
2

TOTAL
33
21/23
(e)        HND I FIRST SEMESTER
COURSE NO
COURSE TITLE
CONTACT
HOURS/WEEK
CREDIT
UNITS
ARC 311
Architectural Design I
5
3
ARC 312
Construction Methods I
3
3
ARC 313
Architectural Delineation I
4
2
ARC 315
Building Climatology
2
2
ARC 316
Site Planning
3
2
MTH 319
Architectural Detailing
4
2
ARC 319
Advanced Algebra
2
2
EE 213
Introduction to Computer Mgt.
 (New Student)*
3
2*
LGE 311
Advanced General English Report Writing
2
2
ARC 318
Theory of Architecture
2
2
GNS 117
Citizenship Education
(New Student)*
2
2*
ARC 314
Technical Report Writing
2
2

TOTAL
29/34
22/26
(f)        HND I SECOND SEMESTER
COURSE NO
COURSE TITLE
CONTACT
HOURS/WEEK
CREDIT
UNITS
ARC 321
Architectural Design II
5
3
ARC 322
Construction Methods II
3
3
ARC 323
Architectural Delineation II
4
2
ARC 324
Estimating & Tendering
2
2
ARC 325
Architectural Structures
3
2
ARC 326
Mechanical Bldg. Services
3
2
ARC 327
Architectural Detailing Ii
4
2
ARC 328
Application & Bldg. Materials
2
2
MTH 329
Advanced Calculus
2
2
LGE 321
Communication in English III
2
2
GNS 321
International Relations (Elective)
2*
2*
GNS 127
Citizenship Education
(New Students)
2*
2*

TOTAL
29/34
22/26
(g)        HND II FIRST SEMESTER
COURSE NO
COURSE TITLE
CONTACT
HOURS/WEEK
CREDIT
UNITS
ARC 411
Architectural Design II
5
3
ARC 412
Construction Drawing I
7
3
ARC 413
Architectural Delineation I
7
3
ARC 415
Elect. Building Services
3
2
ARC 416
Specification Writing
2
2
MTH 419
Numerical Methods (free elective)
2*
2*
BA 215
Principles of Management
3
3
TRP 312
Land Economics
3
3
ARC 417
Principles of Interior Design
2
2

TOTAL
32/34
21/23
(h)       HND II SECOND SEMESTER
COURSE NO
COURSE TITLE
CONTACT
HOURS/WEEK
CREDIT
UNITS
ARC 421
Architectural Design Project
9
4
ARC 422
Construction Drawing II
7
3
ARC 423
Professional Administration
3
3
ARC 424
Introduction to Human Settlement & Housing
2
2
ARC 425
Project Report Writing
3
3
TRP 321
Land Appraisal
3
3
BA 429
Entrepreneurship Development
2
2
BUS 116
Principle of Accounting I
 (Free elective)
2
2

TOTAL
31
20/22

A careful study of this curriculum reveals an overview of the courses in which the students would be taught. These courses are essentially contained in the NUC curriculum for the schools of architecture in the universities but are wider in theoretical scope/content. However, in view of the complexities and dynamism in the practice of the profession, there is the need to break down this curriculum with a view to incorporating the latest innovations in the profession such that areas of specializations in various aspects of the profession can be encouraged. This is why the NBTE / UNESCO partnership programme on revitalizing technical and vocational education should focus on the incorporation of computer and technological innovations in the proposed curriculum.  Musa (2002) in an opinion poll conducted on Ahmadu Bello University, (ABU) Architecture graduates’ views concerning the curriculum and method of training stated that, among other things, “the Graduates wanted to see the expansion of the scope of studies to include courses in the following areas: computer skills and modern information technology management with emphasis placed on computer aided design”.
Similarly, a random sampling of opinion of students of environmental studies of the Moshood Abiola Polytechnic on this issue was also conducted through interviews (2004/2005 academic session). The general outcome also favoured the integration and adoption of ICT programmes in the school curriculum.

INFORMATION AND COMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGY (ICT) IN ARCHITECTURAL TRAINING
Ogunsote and Ogunsote (1987) noted that development in cybernetics and computer technology has affected many aspects of life, even such traditional and ancient profession of Architecture. The 1990’s up to the present day has witnessed more rapid development in computer technology, enhanced application software and improved computer products thereby suggesting an emergence of increased computing in Architecture. In her submission, Okpoechi (2003) opined that “the new millennium has brought with it tremendous advancements in telecommunication and information technology which have been made possible by improvement in the computer as a universal tool for work and leisure. Bobadoye (2002) further corroborated this view thus, “The 1990’s witnessed more rapid development in computer technology, enhanced application software and improved computer products suggesting an emergence of increase computing in architecture, at the dawn of the 20th century, the trend is towards a more universal application of computers to Architecture”. Information and Communication Technology (ICT) in the context of architectural training is the processing and distribution of data using computer hardware and software, telecommunications, and digital electronics. This finds application with the use of software applications such as COMPUTER AIDED DESIGN AND DRAFTING (CADD). Presently, CADD application soft wares are available for use in Nigeria. These include: AUTOCAD, ArchiCAD, GenericCAD, Turbo CAD etc. Of all of these, AUTOCAD based applications (Release14, 2000, 2002, 2004, e.t.c) and ArchiCAD applications are the most widely used. Other relevant or allied software packages include 3D home Architect, 5 in 1 Home design, 3D home interiors, rendering soft wares like Atlantis, Micro station e.t.c.; which are similar used in the production of architectural drawings.  The CAD environment is a virtual studio for the architect, where design could put on paper his / her conceptions, prepare working models and proceed with final presentation and working drawings preparation and production.
It has the following features: import site plans, floor plan work sheet, 3D window section/ elevation windows, photo-realistic modes, mated features and so on.
Okpoechi (2003) listed the following among the innumerable benefits of CAD:
v  Creates accuracy in drawings.
v  Ability to review a drawing several times, while exploring various options.
v  Allows freedom from distractions and unproductive activities, thus allowing the designer to devote more time to design conception.
v  Greater ability on the part of the designer to predict the performance of any design alternative he or she may generate.
v  Possibility of sharing and receiving drawing files with/from other students who are CADD literate e.t.c.
She similarly posited the following as the limitations of CADD to the Nigerian Students:
v    Mechanical failure
v    Power outages
v    Device storage collapse
v    Unauthorized tempering with drawing by another person.
These are the same limitations of other machines and they could be guarded against by the use of UPS (Uninterruptible Power Supply), back-up disks for drawings and a system of security the work environment through the use of access codes and passwords.
Clearly, the merits far outweigh the demerits as each demerit can be effectively checked. CADD programs are particularly useful because as designers, there is the need for visualizing complex forms and shapes that do not exist. As students there are “assignment deadlines”. CADD programs will take care of these, clearly interpreting the information it is fed with, giving satisfaction to the hard working and dedicated students / users.
STAFF DEVELOPMENT TRAINING OPPORTUNITIES
In the world of commerce such as the banking sector, seminars workshops and refreshers courses (within and outside the country) are organized for their personnel who in most cases are already qualified professionals (for example ICAN registered accountants). In the academic sector, there is the Ogun state government sponsorship of selected academic staff for human resources development programmes. In addition, the “train the trainer” programme designed by the digital bridge institute to train the lecturers in Nigerian higher institutions on how to use information technology to deliver their services. This programme also known as the advanced digital appreciation programme – tertiary, is a brainchild of the Nigerian Communications Commission (NCC). This has set precedence for stakeholders in the architectural education sector to upgrade their personnel skill and knowledge, which at the moment seems to be in short supply.
CHALLENGES
As much as there is the need for improvement in the condition of architectural education in Nigeria. There are some salient problems outside the purview of the classroom, but are of equal importance. They include amongst others:
·                     Under-funding which gave birth to superlative and/or aggressive drive for internally generated revenue and has in turn jeopardized quality and / or standard of performance, despite the introduction and the conduct of ‘Post- Jamb’ examination.
·                     There exists spurious correlation of students’ performances at ordinary level (WAEC, NECO, etc) results, with their respective actual performances in the course of study at various higher institution of learning (a common knowledge though!!). This has given rise to corruption, immoral and criminal acts (“Pari ise”, “tun se” etc in the Yoruba parlance as an expression) among students, including parents, even teacher/staff as collaborators, in a desperate bid to secure admission into tertiary institution. Unfortunately, the field of architecture is not left out of this trend. Little wonder then that the quality/performances of students keeps dropping.
·                     There also exist a rising profile of incursion into the field of practice of architecture (activities of quacks, even amongst allied professionals) and a somewhat stiffer and unnecessary competition dictated by the quest for relevance and economic survival. Without concerted efforts by all stakeholders, these problems (and many others) would continue to militate against the progress of the profession, if enduring concerted efforts are not put in place to check these menace.
·                     Some schools of architecture also experience under –staffing in terms of academic and supporting staff. There’s no commensurate number of in relation to the students’ population. Most schools’ do not observe the required carrying capacity standards. No thanks to owner’/operators’ under- funding and the attending survival syndrome…! Courtesy, internally generated revenue!!

SOLUTIONS

There is the need for a drastic overhauling of the present structure of architectural education in all areas such as: training towards and along the followings:
1.                  SPECIALIZATION: The field of architecture is known as a very wide, broad- based and dynamic field. It is becoming increasingly difficult for an individual to be a master of all. This, has given rise to specialization (in which different individuals have different gifts/talents and areas of interest) along the following options:
·                     Landscape architecture,
·                     Design with sub-options as housing, health, hospitality, industrial, institutional, religious etc.
·                     Interior design/decor
·                     Material specifications
·                     Presentation and working/production drawings as 2 and/or 3-dimensional digital works, model-making etc).
·                     Furniture making/building materials and accessories design and manufacturing and products marketing
·                     Construction and project management etc.
Suffice it is to say that, the school curriculum needs to take cognizance of this trend and make necessary adjustments especially in the area of ICT.
Ugboaja (2003) opined that, it is pertinent that the ever increasing dependency of education on computer seems inevitable, because it helps to meet the needs of the students for greater individualization of instruction and greater relevance of subject matter, and the growing expectation of the society for a higher degree of accountability and efficiency in the academic environment and National development. Therefore the school curricula of study cannot afford to be stagnant. Despite the somewhat, introduction of computer appreciation courses in the Architectural programme of the Universities and Polytechnics by the NUC and NBTE respectively, there is still the need for an improvement in the course content, especially on the practical aspects, which should be in tune with the present day realities. To this end, it is important to emphasise the relevant and pertinence of the introduction of intensive courses in CADD, at all schools of architecture so that the issue of presentation and general articulation of complex ideas can be taken care of and such that The curriculum for training young “Architects” would be fashioned out according to the peculiar and prevailing needs. It should also help in the orientation of the students towards adding value to the training.
EXCHANGE PROGRAMME needs to be revived for both staff and students of architecture within and amongst schools’ of architecture and industries/practice (especially) at National and International Levels. This would afford every one the opportunity of exposure, which would in turn enhance quality of architectural education and practice.
CONTINUING EDUCATION: this is necessary for the lecturers / trainers in the areas of professional practice, academic and research be engaged on regular/periodic and/or continuous training exercises in the form of workshop, seminar/symposia, conferences etc as enhancement to the profession.
CONCLUSION
There is the need to make Architecture fit into a tidy study mould that has stable tradition within the academia as some other professional disciplines like medicine, law and engineering. This implies that the method of teaching architecture in our various tertiary institutions need to rise above the usual obsolete traditional methods of theory and project method of studio design modules, and move up to the more innovative, integrated and dynamic methods, which are the hall-mark of the present times. It is rather apt for the present generation of Architecture students and practitioners to be equipped in line with the modern trends just as it is the case with their contemporaries in the developed/developing world. It is a situation like this, which had led to the Architecture programme curricula ‘revolution’ in Europe and America in the 1970s (McLaughlin, 1970). Thus, it is time for such to take place here in Nigeria.
Architectural education in the 21st century no doubt, has gone beyond pencil, paper and chalkboard. The art and science of using lines, shapes to design and create functional spaces for human use no longer solely rely on the use of draughting pens and drawing boards. The versatility of computer aided design programmes has now become a necessity to all students in the design and construction field, not only to be in tune with the trends of the 21st century but also to be useful to the Nigerian society.
The supervisory umbrella of the profession NIA/ ARCON / NBTE / NUC have a role to play. They are required to expand their regulation on architectural education/supervision, vis-à-vis helping in sensitising the appropriate authorities on the need for the students of Architecture to keep up with the challenges of this millennium, and incorporating the application of CADD into the Architecture curriculum at all levels of studies.
These bodies can also set up a committee charged with the responsibility of reviewing and/or harmonising the existing architecture curricular, with a view to making Architecture a full professional and academic discipline in the Universities and Polytechnics. Architectural educators who are versed in the use of CADD should team up to write textbooks/study-manual that will be good alternatives to the foreign ones. These texts will take into cognisance the prevailing socio-economic situation.
In order to achieve this, modern architecture studio must possess all the relevant and necessary tools to condition and/or re-condition the students’ mindset towards meeting the needs of the environment and thus improving their architectural skills. This will in turn, make them competitively relevant in this ICT/computer age.

REFERENCES
Abiodun Olukayode Olotuah (2002): Architectural Education Nigeria: Realization and                          actualization. AARCHES Journal Vol.2, Number 1, 2002 Pp 1-5.
Emmanuel Babatunde Jayeola (2002): Travails of the Nigerian Young “Architect” AARCHES Journal Vol.2, Number 1, 2002 Pp 30-35.
Musa Lawal Sagada (2002): Architectural Education and Practice in Nigeria: Reflections on the contemporary situation AARCHES Journal Vol.2, Number 1, 2002,Pp 21-25
 Nkwogu Uche (2002):  Editorial future of Architectural Education in Nigeria AARCHES   Journal Vol.2, Number 1, 2002 Pp II.
Okpoechi C.O.  (2003): The relevance of CAD in Architectural education NAASCOPE: National Association of Architecture students. 9th edition. Vol.1 2001. Pp 69-73.
Ugboaja u.c.a. (2003): The Internet and the Academic environment: The way forward. 3rd ASUP   National Conference 2003 Book of Abstract. Pp 85.

Microsoft ® Encarta ® (2006):  1993-2005 Microsoft Corporation. 

No comments:

Post a Comment